- Education
- Certificates & Valuations
- Insurance Jewellery Replacement
Jewellery insurance support
Insurance Jewellery Replacement
When jewellery is lost, stolen, damaged or chipped, we help you put together what your insurer needs: a replacement quote, a repair quote or a remake of the original piece.

Quick answer
GemTrove helps with insurance jewellery replacement for lost, stolen, damaged, chipped or missing jewellery, from our showroom at Unit 903/125 Swanston St, Melbourne VIC 3000. We provide replacement quotes, repair assessments, custom remakes, diamond and gemstone matching and valuation support. Raj Sood, a Graduate Gemologist (GIA), reviews your documents and the piece. Your insurer decides the claim. Allow up to 5 weeks; some jobs take a day or two.
How does insurance jewellery replacement work?
When jewellery is lost, stolen, damaged or chipped, replacing it can feel stressful. GemTrove provides the jeweller's side of a claim: assessment, replacement quotes, stone matching, custom-made jewellery, redesign options and valuation support where suitable.
- Gather your documents first: photos, old valuations, invoices, certificates and your insurer's instructions.
- Know what your insurer wants: a replacement quote, a repair quote, a valuation or a damage assessment.
- Lost or stolen jewellery can often be quoted from clear documentation or photographs.
- Damaged or chipped jewellery may suit repair, stone replacement, remodelling or a full remake.
- Final claim approval and settlement conditions are controlled by your insurer and your policy wording.
GemTrove is based in Melbourne CBD and can discuss insurance replacement enquiries for clients in Melbourne, Victoria and other Australian locations, where the insurer's process and practical assessment allow. For how cover works in general, see how jewellery insurance works in Australia.
What can be done for lost, stolen or damaged jewellery?
Lost or stolen jewellery. We review photographs, earlier valuations, certificates, invoices and design details to quote for, or recreate, a suitable replacement where possible.
Damaged jewellery. A damaged piece may need repair, remodelling, stone replacement, setting work or full replacement, depending on its condition and on what your insurer requires. Damaged pieces usually have to be inspected in person before final advice.
A chipped diamond or gemstone is assessed before anything is decided: see our gemstone and diamond repair service and diamond cavities and chips. For a stone that has fallen out, see lost stone replacement and what to do if a diamond falls out of your ring.
Which pieces and which kinds of loss can we quote for?
Any piece of jewellery, and any kind of loss or damage. The quote or report is written for what happened to your piece.
| What happened | What we prepare |
|---|---|
| The whole piece was lost or stolen | A quote to replace it like for like, from your valuation, receipt, report or photographs |
| A diamond or gemstone fell out | A quote for a matching stone and the repair to the setting |
| A stone was chipped or cracked | A damage report, and a quote to recut or replace the stone |
| One earring of a pair was lost | A quote to make the missing earring to match |
| A ring was crushed, cut off or bent | A repair quote, or a quote to remake it if it cannot be repaired |
| A chain or bracelet was broken or lost | A repair quote, or a like-for-like replacement |
| A watch was lost or damaged | A replacement or repair quote |
| A custom or inherited piece was lost | A quote to recreate it from photographs and any records |
| Damage in a fire, a flood or an accident | A report on each piece and what can be saved |
We quote for engagement rings, wedding and eternity bands, earrings, pendants, necklaces, bracelets, bangles, watches, pearls, cufflinks, brooches and loose stones. For how cover works, see how jewellery insurance works in Australia and insurance valuations explained.
Replacement quote, repair quote or valuation: which do you need?
Insurers use different wording depending on the policy and the type of claim. Ask yours which of these they want before you book.
| Document | What it is for |
|---|---|
| Replacement quote | The cost to replace a lost or stolen piece like for like |
| Repair quote | The cost to repair a damaged piece |
| Damage report | What happened to the piece and whether it can be repaired |
| Valuation | A described, dated value for insurance records |
| Quote to recreate | The cost to remake a custom or inherited piece |
A valuation also documents the replacement value after remodelling, a stone replacement, a custom remake or a major repair. See jewellery valuations for insurance, valuation vs diamond certificate, replacement value vs resale value and our jewellery and diamond valuation service.
Not sure what your insurer needs?
Tell us what happened and what your insurer has asked for, and our gemologist will tell you which document fits and what to bring.
Which documents help an insurance jewellery claim?
Before you contact us, gather as much as you can. The more we have, the more accurate the replacement quote or repair recommendation.
- Your insurance claim number, if one has been issued.
- An old jewellery valuation or appraisal.
- The purchase invoice or receipt.
- A GIA, IGI or gemstone certificate, where available.
- Clear photographs or videos of the jewellery.
- Police report details, if required for stolen jewellery.
- Metal type, ring size, chain length, gemstone shape and any sentimental design features.
A grading report describes a diamond precisely enough to match it: see how to read a GIA diamond report, how to verify a GIA report number and GIA vs IGI vs HRD certificates.
Can a custom or inherited piece be remade?
Yes, in most cases. Some jewellery cannot be replaced from a catalogue because it was custom-made, inherited, handmade or is no longer available. We can recreate it from photographs, measurements, old valuations, certificates and design details, using 3D design so you can check the remake against your photos before it is made.
- Natural diamonds suit like-for-like replacement where the original piece used a natural diamond, or the insurer requires one.
- Lab-grown diamonds may be considered when the original item, the policy and the insurer's process allow it, with clear disclosure.
- Coloured gemstones need careful matching for colour, size, durability, treatment and setting suitability.
See lab-grown vs natural diamonds, natural vs lab-grown diamond reports, gemstone colour grading and gemstone treatments A to Z. Remakes follow the same process as any custom piece: see our custom engagement rings in Melbourne page and how to read a CAD render.
How long does an insurance jewellery replacement take?
Allow up to 5 weeks. Many jobs are finished much sooner, and some simple ones take a day or two. The time depends on the work itself, the metal, and whether a stone or a part has to be sourced.
We confirm the time for your piece with the quote, before any work begins. If you need it back for a date, tell us when you book and we will tell you honestly whether it can be done.
This is the time to make or repair the piece once the insurer has approved it. How long the insurer takes to assess and approve the claim is separate, and is up to the insurer.
How much does an insurance jewellery replacement cost?
The replacement figure is worked out for your piece; there is no standard price. A quote is built from what the original was, described as exactly as your documents allow. These are the things that decide it:
- The centre stone. Carat weight, cut, colour, clarity and the type of report. Diamond prices move, so a figure from an old valuation may not be today's figure. See the diamond price guide.
- Natural or lab-grown. The replacement matches the original, and the two are priced very differently.
- The metal and its weight. See how gold prices affect jewellery prices.
- The making. A handmade or heavily detailed piece takes more work to recreate than a simple one.
- Side stones and matching. Pairs and rows of stones have to be matched to each other.
- How much is known. A piece with a report and photos can be matched closely. A piece with no records has to be reconstructed from memory, which is slower.
You can see what comparable diamonds cost today before you speak to your insurer. Every diamond in our catalogue is listed with its grading report and its price.
See today's diamond prices
A written insurance quote is free for a piece bought from GemTrove. For a piece bought elsewhere there is a fee, and we tell you what it is before we start.
What do GemTrove customers say?
These are Google reviews from GemTrove customers, quoted word for word.
5.0 on Google
★★★★★
“… Trusts isn't something that can be written in a few words, it is something to be earned. Buying something with not only high monetary value but of sentimental value depends on a lot of trusts. …”
Whiz
Google review · anniversary ring upgrade
★★★★★
“We got the sizing dramatically wrong and Raj was patient… He had it fixed quickly and delivered an excellent ring.”
Richard L.
Google review · ring sizing corrected
★★★★★
“… His deep knowledge of diamonds and the do's and don'ts of ring design was invaluable. … The craftsmanship and attention to detail are outstanding, and the rings turned out even more beautiful than we imagined. …”
Tanveer D.
Google review · engagement and wedding rings
★★★★★
“… His prompt communication and willingness to help made what could have been a stressful situation completely hassle-free. The craftsmanship, attention to detail, and level of care provided by Neeraj and the Gemtrove team exceeded my expectations. …”
Seno R.
Google review · engagement ring
★★★★★
“Raj is very friendly and knowledgeable on all things diamonds. I went to him to make an engagement ring for me after seeing all his positive reviews. He helped me design the perfect ring. He listened to everything I was looking for and gave me great advice along the way.”
The Adsta
Google review · engagement ring
Read all GemTrove reviews on Google
What happens from first contact to collection?
- Check with your insurer. Confirm what documents they require, whether you can choose your jeweller, and whether they need a replacement quote, repair quote, valuation or damage report.
- Gather your documents. Claim number, valuation, photos, invoices and certificates.
- Book an appointment. Book online or call 0488 878 000. Bring the damaged piece if there is one.
- We assess. The documents, and the piece if it exists, are reviewed and the original is described as precisely as possible.
- We prepare the quote or report in the form your insurer has asked for.
- Your insurer decides. Approval, claim value and the settlement method are theirs.
- The piece is repaired or made once the claim is approved and you have confirmed the design, then checked and handed over with updated paperwork.
What can GemTrove not do in an insurance claim?
GemTrove provides jewellery replacement guidance, repair assessment, replacement quotes and valuation support where suitable. Some things sit with your insurer, and some we will not do:
- Decide the claim. Final approval, claim value, settlement method and replacement conditions are controlled by your policy and your insurer.
- Promise you can use us. Many customers prefer a jeweller they trust, but every insurer and policy is different. Confirm it with your insurer.
- Describe a piece as better than it was. A quote describes the original as the evidence shows it, nothing more.
- Assess damage from photos alone. Damaged jewellery usually needs physical inspection before final advice.
- Give insurance or legal advice. For what your policy covers, ask your insurer or read its product disclosure statement.
For valuations needed for other purposes, see jewellery valuations for estates and family law.
What should you do once the piece is replaced?
- Get the new paperwork. A replacement has its own grading report and needs its own valuation.
- Update the policy. Send the new valuation to your insurer so the item is listed correctly.
- Set a reminder to revalue. See how often to revalue jewellery.
- Reduce the risk next time. See travelling with fine jewellery and our engagement ring care guide.
- Have it checked yearly, so wear is caught before a stone is lost.
If the replacement is lab-grown, see should a lab-grown diamond be insured.
How do you start an insurance jewellery replacement enquiry?
Gather your claim number, old valuation, photos, invoices, certificates and insurer instructions, then book an appointment or call us. The showroom is on Swanston Street, opposite Melbourne Town Hall. GemTrove has been in business since 2008 and our family has been in the jewellery trade since 1984.
- Showroom: Unit 903/125 Swanston St, Melbourne VIC 3000 (Level 9), opposite Melbourne Town Hall, by appointment.
- Hours: Monday to Friday 9:30 am to 5:30 pm, Saturday 11:30 am to 1:00 pm, Sunday closed.
- Phone: 0488 878 000.
- Book: book a replacement appointment. Bring your documents, and the damaged piece if there is one.
Free consultation
Talk to a gemologist
Compare stones in person or online with Raj Sood, Graduate Gemologist (GIA), AJP (GIA).
Book a consultationShop this shape
FAQ
Common questions
Can GemTrove help replace lost jewellery through insurance?
Yes. GemTrove provides replacement quotes and custom remake guidance for lost jewellery, depending on the documents available and your insurer's requirements.
How long does an insurance jewellery replacement take?
Allow up to 5 weeks. Many jobs are finished much sooner, and some simple ones take a day or two. We confirm the time with your quote, before any work begins.
Can GemTrove help replace stolen jewellery?
Yes. We review available photos, valuations, invoices, certificates and design details to quote for or recreate a suitable replacement where possible.
Can GemTrove assess damaged jewellery for an insurance claim?
Yes. We inspect the piece and advise whether repair, remodelling, stone replacement or full replacement is suitable. Your insurer decides what they require for approval.
Can a chipped diamond be replaced through insurance?
It depends on your policy and the condition of the diamond. We assess the diamond, the setting and the replacement options, and provide suitable information for your insurer.
Can GemTrove recreate a custom engagement ring for insurance replacement?
Yes. We can recreate a custom ring from photos, earlier valuations, CAD references, certificates, stone details and design notes, where they are available.
Do I need a valuation for insurance replacement?
Your insurer may ask for a valuation, a replacement quote, a repair quote or other documents. See jewellery valuations for insurance.
Can I choose GemTrove as my jeweller for an insurance claim?
Many customers prefer a jeweller they trust, but every insurer and policy is different. Please confirm with your insurer whether you can choose your jeweller.
Can GemTrove help if I am not in Melbourne?
Yes, where practical. We are in Melbourne CBD and take enquiries from other Australian locations. Damaged jewellery may still need physical inspection before final advice.

Ask a gemologist
Lost, stolen or damaged?
Raj Sood is a Graduate Gemologist (GIA). Bring your documents, and the piece if you still have it, and he will tell you honestly what can be matched, what can be remade and what your insurer is likely to ask for.
Keep learning
Related guides
Buying Knowledge & Custom ProcessHow Jewellery Insurance Works in Australia
Certificates & ValuationsInsurance Jewellery Valuation Explained
Certificates & ValuationsHow Often to Revalue Jewellery
Certificates & ValuationsReplacement Value vs Resale Value in Jewellery
Buying Knowledge & Custom ProcessCustom Engagement Rings Melbourne
Diamond 4Cs & GradingDiamond Cavities and Chips: What Buyers Should Know
Buying Knowledge & Custom ProcessDiamond Price Guide Australia
Care, Repairs & RemodellingEngagement Ring Care GuideExplore more
More guides on this topic
Education
